Expert: the OSCE will not stop the conflict in Donbas instead of Ukraine



2014/11/05 • War in the Donbas

Article by: Yevhen Solonyna

Kyiv – The heads of the OSCE and the Ukrainian MFA discussed on November 5 the possibility of broadening their monitoring mission in Donbas and expressed the will to get involved in helping the forced migrants. The government speaks of the great significance this organization’s support has. Experts accuse the OSCE mission of being reluctant to organize monitoring on the entirety of the Ukrainian border in the conflict area, and sometimes of the pro-Russian positions the observers have taken. Some of the experts emphasize that the positive solution to the conflict can only be influenced by Ukraine itself and possibly the Russian government, and not international organizations. 

OSCE General Secretary Lamberto Zannier will visit the special monitoring mission in Ukraine on Wednesday, the mission reports on its Twitter page. The goal of the visit, as OSCE representatives note, is to discuss the activities and problems of the mission which, in particular, is surveying how events develop in Donbas, where combat continues. OSCE representatives observed the latest parliamentary elections in Ukraine, deeming them democratic and transparent. At the same time, Zannier held several meetings with Ukrainian government representatives.

At the end of the visit, the OSCE General Secretary spoke with Ukraine Foreign Affairs Minister Pavlo Klimkin, reported Andriy Dziubenko, the national coordinator of the programs of the OSCE in Ukraine. He spoke about the goals of the visit and about the OSCE’s foreseeable plans regarding its work in Ukraine.

“They are talking about the numerous issues in cooperation: how can the OSCE, as an organization, be useful to Ukraine? It is an entire range, in particular, about broadening the monitoring mission, and the constant presence of the OSCE coordinator and representatives, which lend project help in all dimensions of security, in our understanding, they include democratization, economy, ecology, military and political aspects,” notes Andriy Dziubenko.

At the end of the meeting he added that the Ukrainian government and the OSCE leadership discussed the details of broadening the mission in Ukraine and the participation of the international organization in establishing Ukrainian national social dialogue. Besides, the OSCE wants to help the forced migrants from Crimea and the war-torn territories of Donbas.

Yakymenko: no illusions about the OSCE solving the conflict

Meanwhile international relations expert Bohdan Yakymenko calls not to overestimate the role of this and other international organizations, as solving the conflict in part of Donbas depends solely on Ukraine and the Russian government.

“We don’t need illusions that such organizations as the OSCE can solve the conflict in Donbas for Ukraine or in its name. The OSCE is unable to regulate a conflict wherein all sides are unwilling. On the occupied part of Donbas the pro-Russian separatists obviously don’t want deescalation, therefore we should not put too much hope on international monitoring missions. Peace in the east is something Ukraine has to agree on with Russia, or what it managed to get back. I don’t see any other possibilities,” the expert concludes.

However, the President’s Administration considers cooperation with the OSCE very significant in the issue of solving the conflict with the separatists and Russian troops in Donbas. As such, recently President Petro Poroshenko emphasized in his address that only Ukraine and the OSCE adhere to the Minsk accords for peaceful regulation. Separatists and Russia, who supports them, sabotage the peace process.

Earlier military experts, including Dmytro Tymchuk, civil activists and media representatives, accused the OSCE of the reluctance to conduct all-encompassing monitoring of the Ukrainian border in Donbas and the conflict zone, and sometimes even accused them of having an obviously pro-Russian position. In particular because of the big number of Russian citizens involved in the OSCE mission in Ukraine.

At the same time, photos appeared online and on Ukrainian TV channels on which pro-Russian mercenaries are getting into a vehicle belonging to the OSCE mission. The mission later confirmed that it did happen, and admitted that such situations are unacceptable and would not repeat again.

At the same time OSCE mission vehicles were attacked by the mercenaries, recently they lost one of their drones which was downed by pro-Russian mercenaries or Russian troops in Donbas. As to the other drone, the OSCE claims in its current report that on November 2 to the east of Mariupol its work over the territory under terrorist control was interrupted with the use of zenith systems, however, they did not manage to hit it. During another raid, the signal from the apparatus was blocked from the territories where separatists are located, with the use of modern radio-electronic methods.

Translated by: Mariya Shcherbinina
Source: Radio Liberty

Tags: ,

  • Brent

    The OSCE needs to regain its credibility and start reporting more truthfully about what is happening in Donbass. There have been too many ‘managed’ messages and it is clear they are trying not to upset Putin and Russia. I’m also amazed the OSCE could have been dumb enough to include Russian citizens in the monitoring mission when it was clear from early on that Russia had involvement in Crimea and Donbass. Considering Russia’s state sponsored terrorists kidnapped two groups of OSCE monitors early in the Donbass conflict and held them hostages should have been the first clue.

    Russia, a country that openly declares it IS NOT EUROPEAN, and that it wants to destroy the EU so it can better control its “useful idiot” puppets who have already sold their souls for Russian favor or money. Russia should be kicked out of the OSCE for its transgressions and its statements it is not part of Russia and its clandestine attempts to undermine the EU.

    No one is asking the OSCE to fight for Ukraine, but you’d think they would better represent the country that wants to join Europe instead of the criminals and thugs that openly detest Europe.

    • Ian Rutherford

      • Michel Cloarec

        In a democratic system which i like to believe I belong to. Everybody has the right of speech ! But it must politicaly correct !
        Therefore can I also say that “bullshit” is not politicaly correct !
        Of course if you are on the payroll of kremlin trolls I understand !
        But feel sorry for you ! Maybe it is possible to save you !

        • Ian Rutherford

    • Michel Cloarec

      I am also confused !
      To me is OSCE an organization which should not include member of the conflict ! (maybe some translators).
      On the other side, I believe that many deciders in the world are reading those reports from OSCE. And untill now, (but some facists), it seems that decisions makers did not change anything about the sanctions towards russia. So the mission of OSCE must have some good points.
      Nobody ask OSCE to fight this war. But I would like to know better the composition of the mission.
      Humanitarian convoys fables could have been dealt with in a better way.
      I still have faith in OSCE, but I do not like their silence when I write to them !

    • Ian Rutherford

      “The OSCE needs to regain its credibility and start reporting more truthfully about what is happening in Donbass.”
      using you as a model, no doubt ..